Then describe all the differences, using compare-contrast cue words such as "differs," "unlike," and "on the other hand," for each comparison. LESSON 1: MAGICAL REALISM IS STILL REALISM ... like Arachne and Pallas would have done for their own pieces. Son of Evander, whom Evander entrusts to Aeneas’s care and tutelage. Both inhabit Louisiana c. Both are confused by other people d. Creoles lived in Louisiana before Cajuns -answer questions 1-10 Step 2 -complete the activity on page 32 that requires you to compare and contrast the text ‘The Scent The story as it appears in the Metamorphoses is the most famous version of Arachne’s fate, and … These are the stories of , the , , and (Metamorphoses 6.1-96). Minerva portrays her contest with Neptune over the city of Athens, as well as the fates of several blasphemous mortals. ... Venn diagram and answer key. Like Arachne was ultimately transformed into a spider due to her offensive textile, Ovid was exiled from Rome by the emperor Augustus at least in part due to the seemingly corrupt vulgarity of his Ars Amatoria. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Students may work by themselves or with a partner. By placing Niobe’s saga after Arachne’s contest with Minerva, Ovid invites us to compare the two women. These changes cause Minerva’s actions against Arachne to appear more as unjustified rage rather than a fair punishment. The two tapestries in the weaving contest convey sharply contradicting attitudes about the immortals. Created by; Lesson 29: Identifying evidence for the culminating writing task. Arachne is like Ovid in that they both have great artistic skill, and their superiors suppress them. The teacher guide for The Transformation of Arachne into a Spider includes the answer key for our text dependent questions, in HTML and PDF formats, and is only available to registered CommonLit users. Compare “Arachne” to another creation myth, … She is a stubborn, independent, talented artist, who is passionate about her work. A 4. The Roman government disapproved of some of his earlier publications such as the Amores due to their carefree nature and subject matter, but it was the Ars Amatoria the regime saw as unacceptable. Pallas, attending to the Muse's song, Approv'd the just resentment of their wrong; And thus reflects: While tamely I … Objective: Students compare and contrast the transformation of Arachne with the transformation of Pallas. Senior Cycle Lesson Plans Field of Study: Later Modern Field of Study Syllabus Topic: (LMI, 3) The Pursuit of Sovereignty and the Impact of Partition, 1912-49 Perspective: Politics and Administration Unit: The 1916 Rising Key Personalities: Patrick Pearse, Eamon de Valera, Michael Collins and Countess Markievicz Key Concepts: Allegiance, Physical Force, IRB, Blood Sacrifice, and Republic She was neither beautiful nor wellborn. However, it is likely that Ovid made minor changes from an existing story to better fit his own complex message. Penelope and the Suitors, John William Waterhouse 1912. Ovid’s audience would have been well familiar with the Homeric epics. Compare and contrast the transformation of Arachne with Pallas. They could hardly be more different. This product can be used in an interactive notebook, or by putting the student pages through the copy machine to create a booklet. Therefore, destroyed and censored work in his stories represents censored literature in Ovid’s world. Although Athena takes pity on her, Arachne still has to be punished in some shape or form. Ovid describes Arachne as a young girl from Lydia who despite her humble beginnings has risen to fame due to her remarkable weaving talent. Thus, Minerva has already been cast as a harsh deity with little pity for mortal women. -answer questions 1-5 Step 2 -read the passage ‘Worth More Than Gold’ -annotate each paragraph and answer questions 1-5 Day 3 Step 1 -Read the passage ‘The Scent of Memory’ and annotate each paragraph. nihil est, quod victa recusem.”, (the belief that she was taught by Minerva) (Arachne) herself was denying, she said “let (Minerva) compete with me! 48 – 51 Compare and Contrast, Summary. This mythological heritage strengthens its correlation with literature, which in Rome, was the counterpart of weaving to Ovid and his peers. -answer questions 1-10 Step 2 -complete the activity on page 32 that requires you to compare and contrast the text ‘The Scent The Transformation of Arachne into a Spider Pallas (Athena, Minerva) is angry hearing that Arachne, a talented, young weaver, doesn’t give the goddess credit for blessing her with spinning skill. Accept any reasonable response. One day, she boasted about being a better weaver than Athena, the goddess of wisdom. Her weaving and confidence are comparable to Ovid’s “carmen et error” (a poem and a mistake), which he credits in his Tristia as the causes for his banishment (Tristia 2.207). Compare and contrast the transformation of Arachne with Pallas. The similarity of their devotion to the arts strengthens the connection between Ovid and Arachne. Therefore, the story shows how upsetting it is for the poet that the Roman government has censored literary works, preventing people from reading them. (CCSS.ELA-LITERACY.RL.5.2) Connections In Text. Compare and contrast the two creatures shown. 'spider', cognate with Latin araneus) is the protagonist of a tale in Greek mythology known primarily from the version told by the Roman poet Ovid (43 BCE–17 CE), which is the earliest extant source for the story. Follow instructions in this video for when to pause it and answer the questions in the handout. Arachne Arachne was a mortal who loved to weave on her loom. On them student write the name of a myth and one of the common characteristics present in that myth. What happens when Katie and her band, Arachne's Web, auditions for their idol? Both are French descendants b. She also displays the victims of Neptune, Apollo, Liber/Bacchus, and Saturn. Also, because Arachne does not back down to Minerva even though she cannot combat her punishment, Ovid portrays her challenge of the goddess as standing up against an oppressive system. Create your free account Teacher Student. Tags: Question 2 . Arachne Arachne was a mortal who loved to weave on her loom. Fill in the Myths and You compare and contrast worksheet. Pallas. ... answer choices . The Transformation of Arachne into a Spider By Ovid From Metamorphoses (Book Vi) 8 A.D. Ovid (43 B.C.-17 A.D.) was a Roman poet well-known for his elaborate prose and fantastical imagery. First name. Arachne (/ ə ˈ r æ k n iː /; from Ancient Greek: ᾰ̓ρᾰ́χνη, romanized: arákhnē, lit. As a class, review answers to the Compare/Contrast handout. Compare and Contrast The Temple of Athena and The Colosseum Stephanie M. Tomaszewski May 7, 2013 Abstract When evaluating works of art, the form of the work, the subject matter, and the content should be considered. Paragraph 2: The opening sentence must contain a transition showing that you are pivoting to discussing differences, such as: "Despite all these similarities, (these two subjects) differ in significant ways." Three assessments are included for 1st, 2nd, & 3rd trimester grades! final part of the comparison will be about how these mythologies have evolved and come to us nowadays, what’s left of them, and it will include the information I got from the interviews. Mortals who called themselves “Jupiter and Juno.” They were transformed into icy mountains. Tip: swipe on touch devices, use your keyboard's ← and → arrow keys, or clicker buttons to quickly navigate the lesson plan. The most famous of the stories she depicts include Europa and Prosperpina, who were both raped by (Metamorphoses 6.1-96). Please ask your teacher to reset your password for you. Preview this quiz on Quizizz. 6 – 10 We participate in the Amazon Associate program. Email address. Ovid describes the parts of the loom and how they are used in great detail in the story of Arachne. If I were defeated, there is nothing. Ovid makes us sympathize with Arachne because of her unfair punishment, her courageous defiance against impossible odds. The tale of Arachne is one of the most famous stories in Ovid’s Metamorphoses. Arachne is a woman from a humble background who makes a name for herself with her talent for weaving; Niobe is a woman of the highest social standing whose reputation rests on wealth, lineage, and family. After the comparison, I will summarize my ideas in the conclusion, where, hopefully, I will be able to answer my questions and prove my hypothesis. After hearing Arachne's statement, Athena confronted her and a contest was planned to occur in three days to see who was a better weaver. Arachne is a woman from a humble background who makes a name for herself with her talent for weaving; Niobe is a woman of the highest social standing whose reputation rests on wealth, lineage, and family. Supplement your lesson with one or more of these options and challenge students to compare and contrast the texts. Choose your grade / topic: Grade 1 - Compare & Contrast Worksheets. This means that if you use this link to make an Amazon purchase, we receive a small portion of the proceeds, which support our non-profit mission. Included are student pages with the text-dependent questions as well as suggested answers. Son of Evander, whom Evander entrusts to Aeneas’s care and tutelage. Previous stories in the Metamorphoses allow Ovid’s readers to form an impression about Minerva’s character before beginning the story of Arachne in Book VI. To read more about the reasons for Ovid’s exile click here. quod tamen ipsa negat tantaque offensa magistra, “certet” ait “mecum! Create a new teacher account for LearnZillion. Pallas. 48 – 51 They could hardly be more different. Because Ovid puts in such a great effort to describe the creation of Arachne’s weaving, the tale suggests the importance of art as a metamorphosis itself from raw materials to a beautiful work. Book: I am Arachne: Fifteen Greek and Roman Myths by Elizabeth Spires pp. Nevertheless in the poem as a whole, the poet’s choices in words, syntax, and subject matter put a different spin on this classic tale. answer choices . Pallas and Arachne, Peter Paul Rubens, 1636-37. Ovid was similar to his literary contemporary, Virgil, in that both authors played a part in reinventing classical poetry and mythology for Roman culture. 2198 times. When looking at the form of the work, determine whether it is two or three-dimensional, what materials and technique are used, and describe line, shape value … Hera. As a group students choose two myths to compare and contrast by arranging the sticky notes on a Venn diagram. Aware of these boasts, Minerva comes to Arachne disguised as an old woman. Arachne DRAFT. A warp-weighted loom, similar to the one described in Ovid’s story of Arachne. If the poet is using Arachne as a foil for himself, the fact that he has established sympathy for the character makes him more appealing in the eyes of his audience. Minerva’s rage drives Arachne to hang herself. Juno turned her into a stork. Arachne refuses, and after Minerva reveals her true identity, the two commence a weaving contest. Senior Cycle Lesson Plans Field of Study: Later Modern Field of Study Syllabus Topic: (LMI, 3) The Pursuit of Sovereignty and the Impact of Partition, 1912-49 Perspective: Politics and Administration Unit: The 1916 Rising Key Personalities: Patrick Pearse, Eamon de Valera, Michael Collins and Countess Markievicz Key Concepts: Allegiance, Physical Force, IRB, Blood Sacrifice, and Republic Objective: Students compare and contrast the transformation of Arachne with the transformation of Pallas. These compare and contrast worksheets help students practice identifying how characters, story details or ideas are alike or different. CommonLit has identified one or more texts from our collection to pair with The Transformation of Arachne into a Spider, based on similar themes, literary devices, topic, or writing style. Her products were well known in Greece and no one has seen any like hers before. This, along with the fact that Minerva’s and Arachne’s tapestries display mythological transformations reinforces the idea that Ovid’s Metamorphoses are a form of beautiful art. Lesson plans. Readings and Materials Book: Greek Myth Plays by Carol Pugliano-Martin pp. Give an overview of the lesson plan, including vocabulary and any special materials needed for the lesson plan. They would have known about the famed weaving talents of mythological women, such as . Even nymphs would secretly watch her. Answer Key 1. Include two details from the drama in your answer. The cause and effect essay explains why or how some event happened, and what were the consequences of the event. Arachne was a famous wool producer that lived in an obscure little village. In contrast, Ovid presents the character of Arachne only in this story, so the reader must form an opinion of her within the parameters of this account. Pallas warns Arachne that “experience comes from lengthened years,” although, stubbornly, Arachne stands her ground. Europa, Acterie, Antiope, Alcmena, Danae, Aegina, Prosperpina, Aeolia, Theophane, Demeter, Medusa, Melantho, King Admetus, two unknown people, Issa, Erigone, and Philyra. This means that if you use this link to make an Amazon purchase, we receive a small portion of the proceeds, which support our non-profit mission. As a result it is easier for readers to see Arachne as a victim, even though she is overconfident and sacrilegious. For the concepts of weaving and writing have long been considered linked. Compare and contrast worksheet B. Who was the goddess of weaving? As beautiful as her works are, the girl firmly maintains that she was not taught by Minerva, the goddess of weaving, and is superior to her. The figure of Arachne resonated with later artists, too, as we see here Gustave Dore’s depiction of the punishment of Arachne for an illustrated version of Dante’s Divine Comedy (1861). B 5. Use a Venn diagram, then write a written comparison. Comparing and contrasting is a fundamental skill both for writing and reading comprehension. A Trojan princess who competed with Juno. Athena. Due to Arachne’s misguided self-righteousness, she believes that her work is god-like. 7th grade. Objective: Students will be able to compare and contrast "The Flight of Icarus" and "Arachne" themes by examining the story's events, characters, and actions. To avenge Pallas’s death, Aeneas finally slays Turnus, dismissing an initial impulse to spare him. Email confirmation. There are many parallels between composing a story and weaving a tapestry (click here for weaving in another Ovidian myth). Minerva was seen as the protector of virginity, so for Arachne to deliberately depict the sexual wantonness of the immortals is a direct slap in the face to the goddess. Who was the goddess of weaving? Reading Plus ® Comparing and Contrasting Taylor Associates COMPREHENSION SK E Lesson G-1 1. a. The compare and contrast essay discusses the similarities and differences between two things, people, concepts, etc. Overall, with the story of Arachne in his Metamorphoses, Ovid uses the challenge of a mortal against a powerful goddess and the destruction of a weaving to represent censorship of literature by the Roman government. She portrays herself in all her glorious armor defeating Neptune in the contest over Athens with a  of a fruiting olive tree to the city. Students analyze The Outsiders using key skills for college and career readiness. Hand out copies of the Compare/Contrast handout (L-8-1-2_Compare Contrast and KEY.doc) and instruct students how to complete it. For Ovid could be using the story of Arachne to offer his own perspective on events in his life. Although Arachne’s weaving is without fault, Minerva is unable to handle her defeat, and destroys Arachne’s weaving and begins to hit the girl with a . Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Readings and Materials Book: Greek Myth Plays by Carol Pugliano-Martin pp. Conversely, Arachne’s tapestry shows   examples of the gods transforming themselves to approach mortals and then take sexual advantage of them. 6 – 10 We participate in the Amazon Associate program. SURVEY . Students compare and contrast the transformation of Arachne with the transformation of Pallas. On them student write the name of a myth and one of the common characteristics present in that myth. Objective: Students will be able to compare and contrast "The Flight of Icarus" and "Arachne" themes by examining the story's events, characters, and actions. Start studying Arachne & Icarus flight study guide. Ovid’s experience with the Roman government is similar to the story of Arachne. Minerva’s tapestry depicts the immortals with absolute power and justifies their actions by showing the mortals whom they punish as arrogant. C 7. Her products were well known in Greece and no one has seen any like hers before. For the girl clearly comes across as vain and overly disrespectful. Also, in order to warn Arachne of the fate that awaits her for challenging the gods, she illustrates four examples of arrogant mortals transformed for the same mistake. Write Use the space below to write your answer to the question on page 95. Scroll over the picture of the loom further down to learn more. A 8. Read our Privacy Policy and Terms of Use. Explain how the author uses the structural elements of drama to retell the story of Arachne. This and the fact that Minerva destroys Arachne’s weaving has powerful connotations for the meaning of the story. 3 hort ResponseS Compare and contrast Alfred’s and Cudred’s traits, actions, and interactions. The two even include some of the same subjects, as, for example, Ovid writes about Europa in Book II of the Metamorphoses. Pallas, however, detested this and therefore disguised herself as an old woman and challenged Arachne to a weaving contest. False. Today, most people see the story of Arachne as a classic, one-dimensional example of a character being punished for hubris. Athena wove a tapestry depicting the gods in These traits attributed to the young weaver could just as easily be used to describe Ovid as a poet: gifted and steadfastedly committed to his poetic project despite the moral authority claimed by Augustus. COPY OF CLASS NOTES FROM LZ LESSON 4-WORD DOCUMENT VERSION . Drancës. It is possible that Augustus credited the Ars Amatoria for corrupting his granddaughter  to the point that he felt it necessary to banish her. Arachne was the best weaver in the loom. Follow instructions in this video for when to pause it and answer the questions in the handout. Aphrodite. After the comparison, I will summarize my ideas in the conclusion, where, hopefully, I will be able to answer my questions and prove my hypothesis. Assigning a separate color for each myth works best (blue = Arachne; yellow = Bellerophone; pink = Athene’s City). Weaving and Writing: the Similarities Between Arachne and Ovid, Pallas Athena (Minerva), by Gustav Klimt 1898. Minerva portrays how Neptune gave the city a salt spring, which was much less useful than her gift. She would weave day and night. Ovid’s Political Message about Censorship in the Story of Arachne. More importantly, because Arachne’s weaving in the story depicts transformations, it is a direct counterpart to the Metamorphoses. C 2. Drancës. Assigning a separate color for each myth works best (blue = Arachne; yellow = Bellerophone; pink = Athene’s City). Q. A 6. Arachne was a weaver who acquired such skill in her art that she ventured to challenge Athena, goddess of war, handicraft, and practical reason. C 3. She advises Arachne to beg the goddess for pardon. Start studying Arachne & Icarus flight study guide. Augustus was aware of this relative’s habits of adultery, Weaving and Writing: Censorship in Arachne, The tale of Arachne is one of the most famous stories in Ovid’s, censorship of literature by the Roman government. Like Arachne, Ovid’s work was found offensive by the powerful, leading them to remove him from Rome, as Arachne was prevented from communicating with people ever again. A man whose daughters claimed they were more beautiful than the gods, and were therefore transformed into steps of a temple. Specifically, he probably changed the tale to make Arachne attempt to hang herself after Minerva destroyed her weaving, making her metamorphosis the thing that saves her life, rather than the punishment itself. Arachne’s Web. By placing Niobe’s saga after Arachne’s contest with Minerva, Ovid invites us to compare the two women. The story as it appears in the Metamorphoses is the most famous version of Arachne’s fate, and we are not entirely sure of the legend’s origins. A Latin leader who desires an end to the Trojan-Latin struggle. An updated version of this lesson plan is available. Students use a Venn diagram to compare and contrast Bellerophon and Pegasus with Arachne and Athena. She was neither beautiful nor wellborn. A. Peter Paul Rubens’ “The Rape of Europa” (1629), which was also one of the scandalizing topics represented by Arachne in her tapestry. She directly contrasts Minerva’s work by showing the gods transforming themselves to trick mortals rather than transforming mortals to punish them. She would weave day and night. To avenge Pallas’s death, Aeneas finally slays Turnus, dismissing an initial impulse to spare him. Arachne, (Greek: “Spider”) in Greek mythology, the daughter of Idmon of Colophon in Lydia, a dyer in purple. Nevertheless in the poem as a whole, the poet’s choices in words, syntax, and subject matter put a different spin on this classic tale. Powered by Headway, the drag and drop WordPress theme, Copyright © 2021 Ovid and the Censored Voice. Middle name (optional) Last name. Book: I am Arachne: Fifteen Greek and Roman Myths by Elizabeth Spires pp. In her weaving, the goddess depicts herself as powerful and benevolent. Pallas eventually dies in battle at the hands of Turnus, causing Aeneas and Evander great grief. Emphasize that they must cite evidence from the article to support their answers. Your email address is safe with us. Students compare and contrast the transformation of Arachne with the transformation of Pallas. Explain how the author uses the structural elements of drama to retell the story of Arachne. One day, she boasted about being a better weaver than Athena, the goddess of wisdom. -answer questions 1-5 Step 2 -read the passage ‘Worth More Than Gold’ -annotate each paragraph and answer questions 1-5 Day 3 Step 1 -Read the passage ‘The Scent of Memory’ and annotate each paragraph. Arachne was a famous wool producer that lived in an obscure little village. Content & Message of the Conflicting Tapestries. You'll gain access to interventions, extensions, task implementation guides, and more for this lesson plan. It is also likely that Ovid changed the story so that Arachne actually wins the contest against Minerva, so the goddess punishes her only because she cannot handle losing to the girl’s disrespectful tapestry. Students compare and contrast the transformation of Arachne with the transformation of Pallas. Afterwards, despite the actions taken against them to halt their skilled work, they both persist in their talents, as Arachne continues to weave as a spider and Ovid composed poetry while in exile. Such an association makes it clearer that Ovid is using the character of Arachne to represent himself. 30 seconds . As a group students choose two myths to compare and contrast by arranging the sticky notes on a Venn diagram. Arachne even maintains this attitude after Minerva gives her the chance to concede (Metamorphoses 6.1-96). D 9. Follow instructions in this video for when to pause it and answer the questions in the handout. You Are Here:   Home » Censorship in Ovid’s Myths » Weaving and Writing: Censorship in Arachne. Vied with Juno, who defeated her, turned her into a crane, and forced her to declare war on her own people. Close reading of the text is required to answer text-dependent questions. We recommend keeping it to 1-2 paragraphs. HINT One way to start a compare– contrast answer is to … What quality is Arachne being punished for, and why does Athena find it so distasteful? He goes into great detail to describe  Arachne’s beautiful tapestries to heighten the tragedy of Minerva destroying these works. Also, in the ancient world, weaving was primarily an activity reserved for women, making it relatively unfamiliar to most of Ovid’s educated male audience. In contrast, Arachne depicts many immoral actions of the gods and their mistreatment of mortals. A Latin leader who desires an end to the Trojan-Latin struggle. Using your notes in the compare and contrast worksheet, on a separate piece of paper, write at least three paragraphs in which you tell how you, or someone else, is similar to one of the mythological characters. People would say Athena must of taught her. After hearing Arachne's statement, Athena confronted her and a contest was planned to occur in three days to see who was a better weaver. True. Lesson 5: Compare and contrast the transformation of Arachne with Pallas, Press ESC or click here to exit full screen. Pallas eventually dies in battle at the hands of Turnus, causing Aeneas and Evander great grief. People would say Athena must of taught her. Add to My Library 142 Add to Custom Reading Set A Winning Smile. There are many lines of Ovid’s version of the tale that support this attitude. This version has intermediate-ruled lines for students in grades 3 through 5.